Easy Key Lime Pie

Happy Saturday!

For some reason the weeks have been just flying by for me – which I’m ok with, as it just brings me to another weekend! 🙂

Last weekend, upon the begging request of my dad, I made key lime pie. I’ve made it before using a couple of methods. One is with a pre-made and/or no-bake mix. Those are good because they don’t have egg in them, but you can just tell they’re fake. If you know what I mean. I’ve also tried making the pie from scratch, which involved eggs. My dad and brother liked it a lot (my mom isn’t a fan of key lime pie), but I of course couldn’t have it.

Which is why I was thrilled when I rediscovered this recipe by Mostly Desserts.


It really, honestly could not be any easier. And the best part? No eggs! This meant I could eat it, and my dad could try the raw “batter” (is that what you’d call it?) that was leftover in the bowl. He claimed it was the best key lime pie he’d ever had!

Once it came out of the oven, he felt the same about it. A success!


Easy Key Lime Pie (egg, nut, gluten? free)
slightly adapted from this great recipe

– 1 (9 inch) premade graham cracker crust (use gluten free if necessary)
– 3 cups sweetened condensed milk
– 1/2 cup plain Greek yogurt
– 3/4 cup key lime juice (<– you must use key limes if you want that distinct taste!)
– 1 tbsp. grated lime zest


  1. Preheat oven to 350*F.
  2. In the bowl of a stand mixer (with the whisk attachment), stir together the condensed milk, Greek yogurt, key lime juice, and lime zest. You don’t have to beat it for too long, just until it comes together.
  3. Pour into the pie crust, and place pie on a baking sheet to make it easy to handle and to be sure it doesn’t overflow and dirty your oven. 🙂
  4. Bake for about 7 minutes. Keep an eye on it as you don’t want it to burn. Just look for tiny bubbles in the middle.
  5. Cool completely and then store in the refrigerator for at least two hours before serving.
  6. Garnish with sliced limes, and enjoy!

– Over the next few months I’m going to try and develop a dairy-free version of this pie. Hopefully I’ll have some success!


You honestly cannot find an easier recipe for Key Lime Pie…or any dessert in general! So with summer pending be sure to keep this in mind for your next get together.

Have a fantastic weekend!


  1. oh man this looks delicious!

  2. My dad has been begging for me to make key lime pie too!!! Where do you get the key lime juice? From actual key limes or do they sell it somewhere? Totally making this.

    1. I’ve done it both ways. I’ve actually juiced the little key limes which can be a pain as there is like 1/2 tsp of juice per lime. But I’ve also bought the juice. It comes in a bottle and in the stores near me it’s either by the smoothies/health food or by the orange juice. Sometimes it’s even near the canned fruit. But both types of juice work really well. I hope you don’t have to hunt too hard!

  3. Yum, looks absolutely delicious 🙂

  4. moderngirlnutrition · · Reply

    Wow that’s way easier than I thought! Definitely going to go on my need to make list. Key lime has always been a favorite

    1. I know, I was surprised by it’s simplicity, too! I hope you like it!

  5. This looks SO good!

  6. It is just GORGEOUS! Like magazine cover edible!

    1. Thank you so much!!

  7. That pie look amazing! I’ll have to try it as soon as the snow melts.

    1. Thanks! Yeah, it’s more of a spring/summer dessert. 🙂

  8. […] it turns out, my most popular recipe on Pinterest right now is this Easy Key Lime Pie. My dad likes it just as much as everyone else, and requested it for Father’s Day. Oh, I […]

  9. […] The recipe is not mine (the picture is), but rather from a friend over at the blog Liv Lives Life. You can find the original post here. […]

  10. […] Easy Key Lime Pie. […]

  11. Tamryne · · Reply

    I am making this right now. The “batter” is delicious. It is in the oven! Thanks! 🙂

    1. Thank you! I hope you liked it! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: